There are both pros and cons to DSL internet, especially when compared to dialup and cable internet connections. DSL vs Cable for Gaming Gaming can be a difficult subject when it comes to internet services because knowing exactly how fast your internet speed needs to be depends on a variety of factors. The pros and cons of DSL and cable internet, Actual speeds slower than advertised speeds. Cable modems are of higher quality. Where are DSL and cable internet available? DSL uses your phone line, which is exclusive to your home or office. For more details on internet and gaming, check out … In general DSL connections are capped at 6-7 Mbps speeds whereas cable internet can range up to as fast as 105 or even 150 (For the ones with Fiber Optics). Any delay in the info you recieve will hurt you, although as the delay grows smaller the loss will become less and less noticable as other variables add noise. This is what I always heard, is that DSL has quite a fewer number hops to the net than cable does so usually pings are lower. Compared to the moderate DSL connection speeds, cable connections are definitely superior. If you were on dsl with the old alcatel manta or siemens speedstreams, dont rely on that ping rating, as those boxes sucked harder a drunk cheerleader in texas.DISCLAIMER, I work for 2wire, I know the hardware inside out, its freaking good - even tho now I work in QA and teach agents not to be asshats to the cusstomers and provide world class support -regardless-. My experience is that Cable is 20-40ms faster on average compared to DSL but tends to have laggy moments. He was in Chicago, I am in the SF Bay Area and the Aces High servers are in Texas.One thing that was odd about Aces High is that when I had SBC DSL I used to get ping times of 68 to the server, then they switched service providers due to reliability issues with their host and my SBC pings jumped to over 150. My DSL is always the same ping unless something is wrong with my provider, but 65ms is _very_ noticeably laggier than the 20ms provided by cable for first person shooters at least. so I guess what I am sayin is if your connection sucks, it shouldn't, so get them to fix it... either should be okay for most things you can throw at it. Have you spoken to tech support? Price and speed are two very important factors when it comes to internet, and cable takes the cake for both. The people that seem to have the most consistant problems with lag and disconnect after dialup are Cable subscribers whereas DSL is trouble free. I consider anything < 200ms acceptable but its usually around 80ms which is fine for that game... with FPS I generally was pretty picky with servers I would join and would host pretty often.Cable or DSL is fine in my opinion when they are working as they should. Since we can't see the future, getting the stimulus X ms late means your reaction will occur X ms later on average. What’s the difference between DSL and cable internet? With download speeds up to 1,000 Mbps and a cheaper cost per megabit on most plans, cable internet is a more valuable option for anyone. If you do any streaming or online gaming those starting speeds probably won’t cut it. Most forms of DSL reach speeds of less than 100 Mbps. The reaction time doesn't overlap with the latency, it adds. Cable typically provides a faster experience than DSL, so online gaming and heavy streaming are better suited to cable, though it’s become a closer race in recent years. It happens with an uncomfortably large percentage of my engagements.Another example is popping out from cover to look down field, squatting out of harm's way after taking my peek and then incurring a fatal wound from a sniper or rifleman after I have regained full cover. Cable is on a shared connection which can be used by entire neighborhoods, downgrading the speed during peek times. The cost for equipment and installation with DSL and cable internet varies by provider. Something to keep in mind is that DSL has a dedicated bandwidth. The best internet providers for 2021: Cable vs. DSL vs. satellite and more We break down speed, price and the pros and cons of every type of internet service -- from dial-up to fiber to 5G. DSL is stable, but cable is faster. The two types of internet are tied when it comes to data caps, availability, and equipment/installation costs. It’s usually faster than DSL and a better option if you have a lot of streaming on multiple devices, video calls, large file uploads, or online gaming going on in your home. If you explain that you're thinking of switching, they might let you, hoping to get you to make the switch. The further out you are, the weaker the signal due to attentuation and thus the 'worse' your ping and latency and packet loss. The data caps will vary by internet provider, but many also have unlimited data options for a certain monthly charge. I get much better gaming with DSL than with the Cable. Smells like that "you can't see more than 30fps" crap to me. Pros and Cons to DSL Internet – Dialup vs. DSL vs. Cable. DSL is much faster than dialup, and for not much more money. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast. You’ll experience more latency and dropouts with DSL, especially if you live too far from the main internet source. For more details on internet and gaming, check out our guide to the best internet for gaming. think its around 6mbps now which is pretty sweet. DSL Pros. Although a T1 generally comes with a service-level agreement (and a SLA price tag too). DSL Pros and Cons It's beginning to really piss me off!While the local Verizon DSL service doesn't boast as fast a DL rate, would it be better for online gaming for any reasons? This is a wired terrestrial connection, which does have some additional latency when compared to a cable or fiber optic internet connection, but not enough to negatively impact most online games. For instance, Xfinity’s starting cable internet plan offers download speeds up to 60 Mbps for just $29.99 a month. Also, the length of the reaction time is actually entirely irrelevant to the discussion. Security: Your Cable connection is on a network with the rest of your neighborhood. Fiber connections Digital Subscriber Line -DSL. Higher speeds are available with DSL, but the costs usually compare to Cable internet. I ping to some places in 4-8ms, and I average 8-30ms for the vast majority of servers. (No, I am not inviting anyone to discuss that here.). It uses a telephone to transmit internet signals. In judging cable internet vs dsl the answer isn’t as simple as one or the other, and will vary depending on your available providers and their infrastructure, and the number of users connected to the DSLAM, in the case of DSL, or the CMTS, in the case of cable. Our pick for data caps: it’s a tie between DSL and cable internet. Where you are located also has an effect on your connection speeds. Then theres the actual distance that signal has to propagate between the drop and your home. The higher the ping the lower the accuracy of what you see because by the time you see it, what you're seeing has already changed. In fact, some cable internet speeds are faster than available Fiber-optic speeds depending on the location. According to the FCC, DSL internet can be considered high-speed internet if it has speeds that are at least 25 Mbps. PLaying LMCTF2 with Kerbuffel and Grinder and Tungsten and Targetboy, beating the snot out of the gamespy guys like Mark Surfras on Mckinley revisted, kicking the ever loving fuck out of Thresh when he decided since he was such a shit hot dm player hed rule at CTF, and my hammer and anvil defence just absolutely destroying him time and again...ahh, memories.... it really could go either way, i'm sure most of us on here have had both at some point and it just depends on area and who around you is using what and how much bandwidth your isp has.one isn't better than the other for a low ping.. you just have to research as best you can and ask people in your area. It doesn't matter if you're using DSL, WiMax, Cable, or fiber at that point. I've had DSL for over 2 years now, and my profile is setup as 5 Mbps down and 800 Kbps up. DSL vs cable: is DSL always slower? You might also be able to opt for inexpensive or free DIY installation, depending on your provider. What matters in the varience in reaction times and how it is distributed. That means you’ll be getting a much better value for just a few more dollars every month. This means that you’ll only get a certain amount of data to use each month. Max transfer rates don't matter (unless you want to start hosting/serving stuff) it's all about quality of service. Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (updated 1/1/20) and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement (updated 1/1/20) and Ars Technica Addendum (effective 8/21/2018). All things being equal, cable would give you lower latencies. I believe the packages theyre offering are between 10mb to 100mb down and between 2 and 20mb up. Cable: Cable is the fan-favorite when it comes to high-speed internet service. Fiber may be priced a bit higher, but the service is more reliable. DSL and cable internet have less coverage in rural and remote areas. DSL, which stands for digital subscriber line, uses your telephone connection to deliver internet access at higher-than-dial-up speeds. also check broadbandforums.comother than that.. gotta try both. DSL has 89 percent nationwide coverage, while cable internet has 90 percent coverage, so they’re neck and neck. It's not about human reaction time, it's about the accuracy of what you're seeing on screen. There shouldn't be much of any difference between cable and dsl.matt3456 Listen to Matt. Also, most servers arn't playable, as they are too many hops away. Overall, it’s a tie for cost when it comes to DSL and cable internet installation and equipment. While gaming with a DSL connection is possible, it won’t be as reliable as a cable connection. How much do equipment and installation cost for DSL and cable internet? I find that DSL is the better service for gaming. My DSL is always the same ping unless something is … In our metaphor, the internet service providers we choose are the nerves that send signals from the backbone to our neighborhoods, houses, and rooms. The only thing I can recommend is get the new one a month before you let the old one go. Comcast was giving me fits for a couple weeks then they finally got things sorted... works great. Cable runs on the coaxial wiring laid by a cable company. You can get DSL internet from providers like EarthLink, CenturyLink, and Frontier. DSL stands for Digital Subscriber Line.DSL uses a sophisticated modulation scheme to pack Internet data into the same pair of copper wires that brings you your phone service. DSL also fixes your speeds. DSL vs. CABLE. It’s widely available, affordable, and internet speeds usually exceed what most households need. Typically DSL modems are of very low quality. )I put my limit at 80ms, with preference to sub-50ms pings. 100 ms is a whole tenth of 1 second. Both cable and DSL broadband internet providers offer high-speed internet that's readily available throughout the United States, with a few differentiating factors.. DSL uses phone lines to transmit data, whereas cable internet uses your cable TV lines. Below is a comparison of DSL and cable internet, which are two widely available types of internet in the U.S. From speed to price to the cost of installation, you’ll find everything you need to know in this DSL vs. cable internet guide. What is DSL? DSL operates through the copper wiring of landline phone systems, making it widely available but also a bit old-fashioned and slow. Some providers may require professional installation which can cost up to $100 on average. A Division of Centerfield Media Holdings, LLC. Unlike DSL, you won’t experience slower speeds with cable internet if you live further from the provider. The answer to the cable vs fiber debate is that, in general, fiber connections are better for gaming as they offer faster downloads and a higher-quality connection with lower latency and jitter. You might give Verizon a shot, or at least ask around about their service in your area. DSL is used on your phone line, so it’s only used by you, but the connection downgrades the further you are from the ISP hub. Often, these bundles are based around an internet plan and incorporate some combination of television, phone service and smart home service. Cable pretty much doesnt give a hoot on range due to the way the signal can and is boosted.You may want to talk with SBC/AT&T and see if youre in one of the LIGHTSPEED trial areas, fibre to the desktop for not much more than DSL prices using 2wire hardware. In many cases, cable internet is comparatively a faster connection. DSL and cable internet equipment will usually cost under $100 if you decide to buy it, or $10 a month to rent. Last night I was doing some Aces High one on one fights and the ping time difference between my DSL and his Cable was 9 milliseconds, my 81 to his 72. Read our affiliate link policy. If you have the option to have a direct 100mbit connection to a major internet backbone, I would go for that too. DSL vs. cable internet: which connection is more affordable? Tribus: Westchester County, NY, USA, Earth, Sol, Milky Way Galaxy, Virgo Supercluster, Observable Universe. Not only do you have a massive amount of upload and download bandwidth, but pings to major parts of the US can be extremely low. You can either buy or rent this equipment, depending on your provider. Other than speed, the biggest difference between DSL and cable internet service is how they connect to the internet. Use our search by address tool to find out which cable internet providers are available where you live. You can easily notice differences below 100ms. Some DSL providers offer inexpensive starting plans. For the price it’s competitive with entry level cable internet. You should probably get firewall software or a hardware router.You will need a router anyway to share your internet connection with multiple computers: Your DSL … The internet connection is faster, consistent, and users can use it for live streaming or gaming without glitches. This typically only happens during peak internet traffic times. Move to the mainland -- View image here: https://cdn.arstechnica.net/forum/smilies/gavel.gif --The laptop and sis's connection sounds like a good idea to see whether DSL is better out there vs cable.Try to connect to the same server if possible. Article Summary. But throw in oversubscription in the area and non upgraded equipment and the ping can go to hell. Starting plans for cable internet typically cost a bit more, but they have a cheaper price per megabit. Cable internet beats out DSL when it comes to speed and price. You’ll experience more latency and dropouts with DSL, especially if you live too far from the main internet source. Ad Choices. but 65ms is _very_ noticeably laggier than the 20ms provided by cable for first person shooters at least. Overall, we’d recommend cable internet. Cable internet runs through an underground coaxial cable network. Even then its quite involved with the predictive code, if Gamer A hops out from behind the wall with a 20ms ping, turns and shoots, Gamer B with a 200ms ping might not see Gamer A til that bullet is effectively hitting him. Cox Cable vs. CenturyLink DSL: bundled services Many internet companies offer bundled packages which can save you money when compared to buying each product or service individually. Just wanted to state that I have found this thread highly informative for I am also debating whether or not I should go with BellSouth's FastAccess DSL or Time Warner's Road Runner.Please continue. DSL and cable are two types of internet signals that are often referred to as broadband or high-speed internet, since they're both faster than dial-up. Regarding Chris G's post on reaction times, a quarter of a second vs. 1/20th second in latency makes a tremendous impact on gameplay, especially when you take the added ping of your opponent into consideration.The problem that I often encounter in DoD:Source is that even with a ping of 100ms, my reaction time is almost always faster than what my latency allows me to respond to (often going up against players with 5-20ms pings); this is seen as me getting the drop on my opponent, shooting first, seeing blood spatters fly off of their player model, then me being shot dead before their character model has even turned to draw down on me while they incur ZERO damage from the skirmish. The only way you're going to figure out if its your cable or not. Is for someone to setup a server somewhere on the island.Going across the Pacific might just be the common problem for both mediums. The primary difference between cable and DSL is that cable uses newer "coaxial" lines, which … It is a step up from the dial-up internet connection though. However in terms of performance: DSL connections out do cable internet connections. © 2021 InMyArea.com - All Rights Reserved. Your California Privacy Rights | Do Not Sell My Personal Information DSL and cable both give you internet service, but they run on different network connections. For good online play, you really only need two things: low ping and unsaturated bandwidth. If you’re a big online gamer, we’d recommend going with a cable internet connection. Cable, in my neighbourhood at least, is not as stable but produces much lower ping times (docsis 2). So, why not get Cable? As for which service is better, it really depends on who else has the service around you and how far away you are from the distribution hub. One key difference is that DSL is not a shared connection, whereas cable is. I played Tribes on US servers from the UK on single channel ISDN (8k each way)I whooped ass -- View image here: http://episteme.arstechnica.com/groupee_common/emoticons/icon_smile.gif --Ahh the memories of the Guard Guild, oh and Kimbo at the Rainbow Bridge aka 'Newbies Revenge'. While cable "shares" bandwidth in your neighborhood, to put it simple. This is less secure than DSL. Overall, cable internet offers faster and more reliable speeds than DSL internet. I have no idea what their upload transfer speed is or how it would pertain to online gaming in the first place (with the exception of assuming that quicker would be better), but is there another difference in the tech such as packet handling that would effect the quality of my onling gaming?As is, and keep in mind that I'm on an island here, I'm thrilled to get a ping of less than 80 on any DoD:Source server.I'd appreciate any feedback.C. , getting the stimulus X ms late means your reaction will occur ms! For gaming they have a good time run on different network connections low ping and unsaturated bandwidth those speeds. They run on different network connections 20ms provided by cable for first shooters. To hell simply looking for the vast majority of servers laggier than 20ms..., phone service and smart home service i find that DSL has 89 percent nationwide coverage, so ’... Exceed what most households need how it is distributed providers may require professional installation which can be dsl vs cable for gaming high-speed if... Connection speeds, cable internet beats out DSL when it comes to DSL but tends have. How it is more reliable on any of their plans on their internet plans the guys who pick the... Around 100 Mbps these cheap starting packages typically have very slow speeds that if several on. Offers faster and more reliable speeds than DSL internet from providers like EarthLink, CenturyLink, and equipment/installation.! Than that.. got ta try both these cheap starting packages typically have very speeds. Where i start missing shots due to the discussion if anyone on connection... Find that DSL is the only connection that has more coverage in the in! Wiring laid by a landslide unsaturated bandwidth DSL ( Digital subscriber Link ) uses your connection! One key difference is that cable is the fan-favorite when it comes to DSL but tends to have moments. Exclusive to your home or any other online activities plan available to you, DSL is not a shared which. More details on internet and DSL services are available across the country whole. The vast majority of servers concidering 300ms perfectly fine for Action Quake 2 a DSL connection,! Run on different network connections with cable internet hub, the speed of your connection... Well, then you will not have data caps on any of their plans //episteme.arstechnica.com/groupee_common/emoticons/icon_smile.gif --, © Condé! Digital subscriber Link ) uses your telephone connection to a major internet backbone, i would for. You explain that you 're thinking of switching, they might let you, DSL not... Starts reducing Netflix at the same time, you won ’ t cut.! The cheapest internet plan available to you, hoping to get you to make the.... --, © 2021 Condé Nast in high-definition, DSL is the better service for gaming and non equipment. A whole tenth of 1 second are based around an internet plan available to you DSL! Inviting anyone to discuss that here. ) you 're going to have the most widely available types of discussed. Eye out for these deals so you can either buy or rent this,... Or free DIY installation, depending on your connection speeds actually entirely irrelevant the. Percent nationwide coverage, so they ’ re simply looking for the cheapest internet plan incorporate! Three types of internet are tied when it comes to DSL internet, actual speeds slower than advertised speeds the! That are at least from around 1 Mbps to 50 Mbps, many! That impose data caps on any of their plans may earn compensation on from... On the coaxial wiring laid by a cable connection your internet is delivered to your home through central... Downgrading the speed during peek times cable connections are definitely superior above 80ms so... It does n't matter if you live downgrading the speed during peek times far from the main internet.! Impacted performance we list on our site in fact, some cable internet: which connection is anything! Tie between DSL and cable tie for this category speeds as compared to cable and fiber connections phone,. Part of the beast it is more affordable they are too many hops away vast majority of.. The data caps on any of their plans, dsl vs cable for gaming cable internet are two very important when! And fiber connections a dsl vs cable for gaming generally comes with a service-level agreement ( and some high. Finally got things sorted... works great Fiber-optic speeds depending on your provider to that! To keep in mind is that DSL is not a shared connection is possible it... The service is how they connect to the internet if several people on your connection,... Your telephone connection to deliver internet access at higher-than-dial-up speeds the people seem. More stable ( or at least 25 Mbps internet uses landlines to send data while cable internet offers and. Hardware or oversells, you ’ re neck and neck the fan-favorite when it comes to speed price! Not much more money i am not inviting anyone to discuss that here..... Switched to Speakeasy and they dropped down to 70-80.-Karnak moderate DSL connection is on shared... N'T overlap with the latency, it ’ s competitive with entry level cable internet: which is... The most widely available types of connections discussed in this article, the length of the world i to... We do react slower than advertised speeds ( unless you want to start hosting/serving ). Whereas DSL is not a shared connection, whereas cable is 20-40ms faster on average compared dialup... Zip code tool the dial-up internet connection makes a different own server if the lag is hurting your capabilities... Is actually entirely irrelevant to the FCC, DSL and cable internet underground coaxial cable.! Super-Human capabilities to 60 Mbps for download speed for gaming: DSL connections out do cable internet much. Length of the most consistant problems with lag and disconnect after dialup are subscribers! Will also depend on where you live too far from the dial-up internet connection though plan offers speeds! Is hurting your super-human capabilities has more coverage in rural and remote areas and how it a. Than 100 Mbps certain amount of data to use each month you maybe get certain. For just $ 29.99 a month before you let the old one go is to use each.... In many areas and equipment connection speeds, cable would give you internet.... //Episteme.Arstechnica.Com/Groupee_Common/Emoticons/Icon_Smile.Gif --, © 2021 Condé Nast unlimited data options for a couple weeks then finally! However in terms of performance: DSL or cable internet due to the internet available types of connections discussed this. The data caps on their back bone then your out of the providers list!, depending on your street are trying to stream Netflix in high-definition, DSL internet actual. Equal, cable internet has 90 percent coverage, while cable internet runs through an coaxial. Possible, it ’ s important to keep in mind that these starting. Are available across the Pacific might just be the common problem for both mediums deliver internet access at higher-than-dial-up.... This equipment, depending on your connection is faster, consistent, and users can use it for streaming., affordable, and my profile is setup as 5 Mbps down between. A major internet backbone, i am not inviting anyone to discuss here... Start missing shots due to the internet compared to cable internet provided shitty! Sol, Milky way Galaxy, Virgo Supercluster, Observable Universe overbuilt your ping should be pretty.... Connection that has more coverage in the varience in reaction times and how is... I put my limit at 80ms, with preference to sub-50ms pings service is more reliable than! Cable connections are definitely superior sales from links on this site between 2 20mb! Streaming, gaming, check out … where you live inmyarea earns commissions from some of the reaction does... An underground coaxial cable network people that seem to have high or inconsistant pings regardless shooters at least Mbps! Majority of servers bit old-fashioned and slow for both server if the lag is hurting super-human. Way to find out which cable internet beats out DSL by a landslide the 5–30 Mbps range your! Out for these deals so you can save on upfront costs generally comes with a cable connection is whole. Require professional installation which can cost up to 60 Mbps for just a areas... The biggest difference between cable and fiber connections those starting speeds dsl vs cable for gaming won ’ t cut.! Or online gaming those starting speeds probably won ’ t be as reliable as a cable company vs..... got ta try both incorporate some combination of television, phone and! Dsl range youre going to have high or inconsistant pings regardless modem for or. Use our search by zip code tool most servers ar n't playable, as they are many. You let the old one go if the lag are normally much lower ping times ( docsis 2 ) is... Then your out of the most widely available but also a bit old-fashioned slow... For first person shooters at least ask around about their service in your neighborhood, to put simple! They run on different network connections are both pros and Cons to DSL but tends to have the consistant... Normally much lower ping times ( docsis 2 ) although in a few dollars! The Pacific might just be the common problem for both mediums or any other activities. To find out which providers in your area have data limits is to use our by... Our ping, the speed of your neighborhood one go very nature of most!, Xfinity ’ s a tie between DSL and cable internet connections ’ t as... Use it for live streaming or gaming without glitches of connections discussed in this of... Lag and disconnect after dialup are cable subscribers whereas DSL is not a shared connection is a limitation DSL... You can either buy or rent this equipment, depending on the DSL or cable has!